Jeff Michalic

Jeff is an experienced land broker who specializes in various types of properties such as residential, investment, tillable, recreational, and hunting lands. With over 30 years of marriage, he and his wife Buffy are proud parents to three children: Madison, Hunter, and Ben. Having grown up in western Indiana, Jeff has a deep understanding of people's connection to land and their love for the outdoors. When he's not busy helping clients buy or sell properties, Jeff enjoys engaging in outdoor activities like bow hunting for whitetail deer and turkeys, fishing, land management, and coaching.

Jeff's true passion lies in managing properties to grow and hunt mature trophy whitetails. He combines this passion with his extensive knowledge of real estate to become the go-to guy for buying or selling land in Indiana. Jeff's exceptional skills in the field have earned him 5-time Pinnacle Club awards for sales in the nation. He was awarded the 2024 Fox Haas Award. From 2017 -2024 Jeff has sold over 25,000 acres. You can easily get in touch with Jeff through his cell phone at 812-230-4503 , office at 765-505-4155 , or email at jeffm@mossyoakproperties.com.

View My Listings

Testimonials

Recreational Buyer
Working with Jeff Michalic and his team is always a pleasure. He is very efficient and balanced and knows the local markets very well. Jeff has been a trusted advisor on land related matters and very helpful when acquiring land. He has also introduced me to valuable contractors and other contacts that make the management of the properties easier and more efficient. I am looking forward to continuing to work with Jeff and his team on new acquisitions. Fabio T.
Fabio Terlevich Indiana
Land Buyer
Jeff was well informed and did a great job coaching me thru the land acquisition process.
Jim Adams Illinois
Buyer and Seller
We spent quite a bit of time with Jeff in our pursuit of looking for a house with hunting property, and were very impressed with him. Jeff was very knowledgeable and knew exactly what we were looking for. We liked him so well, we hired him to sell our property for us in Illinois, and he did an excellent job. He has become a good friend in the whole process, and we would highly recommend Jeff and Mossy Oak Properties.
Mark and Linda Walbright Indiana - Illinois
Owner
I would like to thank Jeff Michalic for his professional expertise and tenacity in handling the sale of our family farm in Indiana. I am also a real estate broker (in Montana), and this sale was one of the most difficult transactions I have ever been involved in. It required two surveys and an attorney to consummate the sale. Jeff stayed on top of every step and reported every progress or setback as each occurred. I highly recommend Jeff to represent you in the sale or purchase of your property.
Jolynne Vermillion County
Seller
Our mother, who passed had farmland in Vigo County, Indiana since the 1950s. We decided to put the land up for sale (188 acres). We searched for realtors and were very happy to come across Jeff Michalic. From our first conversation, Jeff was professional, knowledgeable, honest, and personable. And in spite of the land sitting idle for a few years with no crops and having limited access, Jeff managed to find perspective clients. He even recommended a local farmer, which we hired to clear the land and plant crops. After about a year of not much interest, Jeff was open to discussing a new strategy and made suggestions on how to lower the price and entice a variety of potential buyers. It included considering wetland programs, and leasing part of the land for hunting and fishing. This strategy worked, and we recently negotiated a cash offer with a buyer. For these reasons, I highly recommend Jeff as a realtor who specializes in farmland on the IL and IN sides.
Samone A. Vigo County Indiana

Land for Sale by Jeff Michalic

New Listing
Edgar County, IL
4542 N 2150th Street, Paris, IL – 10.28 AcresLocated in eastern Edgar County, just minutes from the Illinois–Indiana state line, this 10.28-acre property offers the perfect combination of space, comfort, and rural charm.The home is a 3-be...
10.28± Acres
|
$310,000
New Listing
Sullivan County, IN
Lost Acres Farm – 164 Acres | Sullivan County, INThis incredible 164-acre trophy whitetail property in West Central Indiana is unlike any other. Located in Sullivan County, it offers both premier hunting opportunities and long-term investment v...
164± Acres
|
$1,040,000
Under Contract
Vermillion County, IN
Building Site Alert Rural Alert!Location: Nestled in the serene beauty of Vermillion County, Indiana, just a short drive northwest of Clinton, awaits this gem of land on West County Road 1300 South.Property Details: Size: A spraw...
8.1± Acres
|
$95,000
Under Contract
Clay County, IN
3640 West County Road 1385 North, Rosedale, IndianaLocated in northwest Clay County, this 6.38-acre parcel offers the perfect blend of open space and wooded seclusion—ideal for building your dream home, creating a weekend cabin retreat, or enjo...
6.38± Acres
|
$75,000
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
703 N Fruitridge Avenue – Terre Haute, IN2.05 Acres – Two Commercial Pole Buildings – Prime Fruitridge LocationLocated along well-traveled Fruitridge Avenue, this 2.05-acre commercial property offers excellent visibility and easy ac...
2.05± Acres
|
$550,000
New Listing
Madison County, IN
1806 Noble Street, Anderson, INBuild your dream home on this beautiful open lot located in a quiet and established neighborhood! This spacious 0.28-acre parcel offers the perfect canvas for new construction. Enjoy the natural beauty and privacy provi...
0.28± Acres
|
$20,000
Under Contract
Vigo County, IN
4436 S Hidden Way Street – Cozy, Comfortable, and Convenient Living!Located in the desirable Hidden Court Subdivision on Terre Haute’s south side, this charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroomhome is move-in ready and full of welcoming features.Int...
0.15± Acres
|
$185,000
New Listing
Vermillion County, IN
Brand-New Modern Retreat on 2.7 Acres — Be the First to Call It Home!Welcome to your own private escape—this brand-new construction home sits on 2.7 wooded acres and blends custom design, high-end finishes, and modern efficiency with a pe...
2.7± Acres
|
$395,000
New Listing
Iroquois County, IL
For Sale: Premier 112-Acre Country Estate – 2167 E. 1170 North Road, Milford, IL 60953Welcome to your dream country escape! This 112-acre estate in Milford, Illinois offers a rare combination of productive land, luxury living, and turn-key...
112± Acres
|
$1,265,000
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Sarah Myers Tillable – 31 Acres of Prime Development or Ag GroundLocation: West Vigo County, IndianaThe Sarah Myers Tillable is a 31-acre tract located on the west side of Vigo County, offering an excellent opportunity for agricultural use or f...
31± Acres
|
$420,000
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Sugar Creek 30 – Vigo County, IndianaThe Sugar Creek 30 is a 30-acre recreational property located in western Vigo County, just north of West Vigo High School. This tract features approximately 0.40 miles of frontage on Sugar Creek, offering ye...
30.81± Acres
|
$154,050
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Sugar Creek 40 – Vigo County, IndianaThe Sugar Creek 40 is a 40+ acre recreational property located in western Vigo County, just north of West Vigo High School. This tract features approximately three-quarters of a mile of frontage on Sugar Cre...
40.59± Acres
|
$202,500
Price Reduced
Vermillion County, IN
6913 South County Road 50 West, Dana, IN 47847Western Vermillion County | Historic Farmstead | 6 Bed | 2 Bath | 54x104 Pole Barn / 3.4 +/- acresLocated in western Vermillion County just southeast of Dana, Indiana, this timeless farmstead is rich in l...
3.4± Acres
|
$350,000
Price Reduced
Vermillion County, IN
660 Mulberry Street | Clinton, IndianaFully Renovated | 2 Bed | 2 Bath | Detached GarageWelcome to this beautifully renovated home in Clinton, Indiana. Every aspect of this residence has been updated to blend classic charm with modern functionality. ...
0.13± Acres
|
$205,000
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Trinity Tillable – 196.47± Acre Irrigated Investment Farm on Reclaimed Ground – Western IndianaLocation: Western IndianaTotal Acreage: 196.47± Acres Tillable (FSA): 149.20± Acres Irrigated Acres: 120.50±...
196.5± Acres
|
$1,500,000
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Sugar Creek 68 – Vigo County, IndianaProperty Overview:Sugar Creek 68 is a productive 68-acre parcel located in western Vigo County, just west of West Terre Haute, Indiana. With 56.3 acres of tillable ground out of 67.5 total deeded acres, this...
67.5± Acres
|
$445,000
Price Reduced
Vigo County, IN
625 W Rigney Drive, Terre Haute, IN 47802Residential Building Site | 1.04 Acres | Central Vigo CountyWelcome to 625 W Rigney Drive, a prime 1.04-acre residential building site located in central Vigo County. This lot once housed a residence, but the ...
1± Acres
|
$90,000
New Listing
Putnam County, IN
Byrd Branch Creek 128128 Acres | 3,316 Sq Ft Home | Putnam County, IndianaWelcome to Byrd Branch Creek 128, a premier residential farm located in scenic western Putnam County, Indiana. This 128-acre property offers a perfect blend of luxury country l...
128± Acres
|
$1,250,000
Price Reduced
Crawford County, IL
Crawford County Whitetails and Waterfowl Paradise – 276 Acres on the Wabash RiverWelcome to a one-of-a-kind 276-acre outdoor haven, nestled along the picturesque Wabash River in Crawford County, Illinois. This property offers the perfect blend ...
276± Acres
|
$750,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #4 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #3 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #2 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #1 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
Under Contract
Clay County, IN
Prime Vacant Land - Wooded & Tillable - Perfect for Recreation or FarmingProperty Overview:This expansive 119.5-acre property offers the best of both worlds: beautiful wooded areas for recreation and a portion of productive tillable land. Located...
119.5± Acres
|
$570,000
1
2

Contact Jeff Michalic