Jeff Michalic

Jeff is an experienced land broker who specializes in various types of properties such as residential, investment, tillable, recreational, and hunting lands. With over 29 years of marriage, he and his wife Buffy are proud parents to three children: Madison, Hunter, and Ben. Having grown up in western Indiana, Jeff has a deep understanding of people's connection to land and their love for the outdoors. When he's not busy helping clients buy or sell properties, Jeff enjoys engaging in outdoor activities like bow hunting for whitetail deer and turkeys, fishing, land management, and coaching.

Jeff's true passion lies in managing properties to grow and hunt mature trophy whitetails. He combines this passion with his extensive knowledge of real estate to become the go-to guy for buying or selling land in his area. Jeff's exceptional skills in the field have earned him four-time Pinnacle Club awards for sales in the nation, having sold over 50,000 acres from 2018 to 2023. You can easily get in touch with Jeff through his cell phone at 812-230-4503 , office at 765-505-4155 , or email at jeffm@mossyoakproperties.com.

View My Listings

Testimonials

Recreational Buyer
Working with Jeff Michalic and his team is always a pleasure. He is very efficient and balanced and knows the local markets very well. Jeff has been a trusted advisor on land related matters and very helpful when acquiring land. He has also introduced me to valuable contractors and other contacts that make the management of the properties easier and more efficient. I am looking forward to continuing to work with Jeff and his team on new acquisitions. Fabio T.
Fabio Terlevich Indiana
Land Buyer
Jeff was well informed and did a great job coaching me thru the land acquisition process.
Jim Adams Illinois
Buyer and Seller
We spent quite a bit of time with Jeff in our pursuit of looking for a house with hunting property, and were very impressed with him. Jeff was very knowledgeable and knew exactly what we were looking for. We liked him so well, we hired him to sell our property for us in Illinois, and he did an excellent job. He has become a good friend in the whole process, and we would highly recommend Jeff and Mossy Oak Properties.
Mark and Linda Walbright Indiana - Illinois
Owner
I would like to thank Jeff Michalic for his professional expertise and tenacity in handling the sale of our family farm in Indiana. I am also a real estate broker (in Montana), and this sale was one of the most difficult transactions I have ever been involved in. It required two surveys and an attorney to consummate the sale. Jeff stayed on top of every step and reported every progress or setback as each occurred. I highly recommend Jeff to represent you in the sale or purchase of your property.
Jolynne Vermillion County
Seller
Our mother, who passed had farmland in Vigo County, Indiana since the 1950s. We decided to put the land up for sale (188 acres). We searched for realtors and were very happy to come across Jeff Michalic. From our first conversation, Jeff was professional, knowledgeable, honest, and personable. And in spite of the land sitting idle for a few years with no crops and having limited access, Jeff managed to find perspective clients. He even recommended a local farmer, which we hired to clear the land and plant crops. After about a year of not much interest, Jeff was open to discussing a new strategy and made suggestions on how to lower the price and entice a variety of potential buyers. It included considering wetland programs, and leasing part of the land for hunting and fishing. This strategy worked, and we recently negotiated a cash offer with a buyer. For these reasons, I highly recommend Jeff as a realtor who specializes in farmland on the IL and IN sides.
Samone A. Vigo County Indiana

Land for Sale by Jeff Michalic

New Listing
Crawford County, IL
Crawford County Whitetails and Waterfowl Paradise – 276 Acres on the Wabash RiverWelcome to a one-of-a-kind 276-acre outdoor haven, nestled along the picturesque Wabash River in Crawford County, Illinois. This property offers the perfect blend ...
276± Acres
|
$883,072
Under Contract
Parke County, IN
For Sale: 5.5 Acres of Rural Charm on New Discovery Road, Parke County, IndianaDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and peaceful seclusion on this 5.5-acre property in central Parke County, Indiana. Located on scenic New Discovery Road, this ...
5.56± Acres
|
$66,800
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #4 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #3 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #2 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
For Sale: Lot #1 Cory Staunton Road – A Serene Rural Building SiteDiscover the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience on this approximately 4-acre wooded parcel, located along Cory Staunton Road. This tranquil rural building sit...
4± Acres
|
$99,000
Under Contract
Vermillion County, IN
The Sandytown 7Sale: 13766 S County Road 100 E, Clinton, Indiana Price: $85,000.00This property is a true diamond in the rough, offering endless possibilities for the right buyer. Nestled on 7 acres, it features a mix of 2.5 acres of open pastur...
7± Acres
|
$85,000
Price Reduced
Vermillion County, IN
Charming Clinton Home with Bonus Lot - A Cozy Retreat with Endless Possibilities!Welcome to this inviting 2-bedroom, 1-bath home nestled at the far north end of Main Street in Clinton, IN, 47842. This cozy residence spans 1,260 square feet and featur...
1± Acres
|
$72,500
Under Contract
Vermillion County, IN
For Sale: 93 Acres of Prime Tillable and Recreational LandProperty Overview:Welcome to The Universal Tillable, a remarkable 93-acre farm situated just west of Universal, Indiana, and west of Clinton, Indiana. This versatile land offers 68 tillable ac...
93± Acres
|
$511,500
Under Contract
Sullivan County, IN
The Thunderbird – 376 Acres of Natural Beauty and Wildlife Habitat in Northern Sullivan County, IndianaWelcome to The Thunderbird, a sprawling 376-acre property nestled in northern Sullivan County, Indiana. This unique piece of land is the site...
376± Acres
|
$1,400,000
Under Contract
Clay County, IN
Lakefront Paradise on 6060 N County Road 300 E, Brazil, INThis 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home offers a spacious 2,832 square feet, all on a single level—perfectly designed for both intimate family moments and larger gatherings. The home boasts an a...
55.5± Acres
|
$595,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
Prime Vacant Land - Wooded & Tillable - Perfect for Recreation or FarmingProperty Overview:This expansive 119.5-acre property offers the best of both worlds: beautiful wooded areas for recreation and a portion of productive tillable land. Located...
119.5± Acres
|
$570,000
Price Reduced
Vermillion County, IN
Welcome to Your Next Opportunity at 667 Davis StreetNestled in the heart of Clinton, IN, this mixed-use property offers the perfect blend of residential comfort and commercial potential. Spanning a combined lot size of 0.51 acres, including a vacant ...
0.51± Acres
|
$155,000
Price Reduced
Vermillion County, IN
For Sale: The Hilly 56 - Prime 56-Acre Hunting Property in Vermillion County, INDiscover the Hilly 56, a stunning 56-acre property located in northern Vermillion County, Indiana, just 3 miles northwest of Cayuga and a half-mile from the Indiana-Illin...
56± Acres
|
$330,000
New Listing
Parke County, IN
Wabash River 132 - Prime Recreational Land in Northwest Parke CountyDiscover the potential of the Wabash River 132, a stunning 132-acre property located in the picturesque northwest corner of Parke County. This unique parcel boasts over half a mile o...
132.7± Acres
|
$750,000
Under Contract
Parke County, IN
For Sale: Picturesque 71-Acre Property in Parke County, Indiana Address: 927 E 750 S, Bloomingdale, IN Price: $859,000.00 Picture yourself sitting on the front covered porch or rear open deck with a warm drink as the morning sun chases away the pr...
71± Acres
|
$795,000
Under Contract
Parke County, IN
The Parke County Catlin 69Welcome to a prime 69-acre property located just south of Rockville, Indiana. Nestled in the heart of Parke County, an area renowned for its covered bridges, the Covered Bridge Festival, and exceptional hunting opportunities...
69± Acres
|
$425,500
Price Reduced
Vermillion County, IN
Welcome to your own slice of wilderness retreat just north of Clinton, IN! Located on County Road 100 East, this 25-acre recreational property is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts and hunters alike.Surrounded by abundant agriculture, this property serv...
24.53± Acres
|
$149,000
New Listing
Vermillion County, IN
Attention golfers and new home site lookers.Discover the perfect canvas for your dream home at Lot 19 Golf Lane, ideally situated just west of Clinton, Indiana. Spanning an expansive .64 acres, this ready-to-build lot boasts a flat terrain and conven...
0.64± Acres
|
$20,000
Price Reduced
Vermillion County, IN
Secluded Recreational Paradise in Vermillion County, IndianaNestled just north of Clinton in picturesque Vermillion County, this stunning 15-acre property is a nature lover's dream. Boasting a mix of wooded terrain, this parcel offers an ideal settin...
15± Acres
|
$89,000
Price Reduced
Vigo County, IN
Introducing W Sarah Myers Drive 12 – a captivating haven tucked away in the scenic landscape of western Vigo County. This property is a rare gem, offering an unparalleled opportunity for your dream home or weekend retreat.Features:Secluded Wood...
12± Acres
|
$120,000
Price Reduced
Vigo County, IN
Introducing Thorpe Road 25 – a captivating haven tucked away in the scenic landscape of western Vigo County. This property is a rare gem, offering an unparalleled opportunity for your dream home or weekend retreat.Features:Secluded Woods: Embra...
25± Acres
|
$187,500
Price Reduced
Vigo County, IN
Thorpe Road 17 - Your Ideal Retreat Awaits!Welcome to Thorpe Road 17, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque landscape of western Vigo County. This property offers the perfect blend of natural beauty and convenience, making it an exceptional investm...
17± Acres
|
$127,500
Price Reduced
Parke County, IN
Welcome to 4964 S. Timberlake Circle, a stunning property nestled in the highly sought-after Parke County, Indiana. This remarkable home offers an abundance of features and a prime location within the prestigious Timberlake gated community. Prepare t...
20± Acres
|
$500,000
1
2

Contact Jeff Michalic