For Sale Paxton Home and Development

Sullivan County Indiana
2.46+/- Acres

Ask Jeff Michalic

Property Information

ID: 20638
External ID/MLS: -- / N/A
Status: Available
Price: $99,900
Acres: 2.46 +/-
Address: 1399 & 1431 E Paxton Depot Street
City, State: Carlisle, Indiana
County: Sullivan
ZIP Code: 47838
Presented By: Jeff Michalic
Taxes: $1,607
Dwelling Sq Ft: 2,140
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2


1399 and 1431 E Paxton Depot Street is located in Sullivan County in the small town of Paxton. The home at 1431 is on a corner lot with 2140 square feet and has 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms. This home is in need of some work but is mostly complete. The home had a garage fire in 2020; since that time,  the garage has been removed and the home is now ready for a new owner. The east side of the home does have some smoke and fire damage but it only affects the laundry room and a small office. The owners were in the process of remodeling the home at the time of the fire, so some other additional work needs to be completed. This home sits on 1.62 acres, which the county has divided into 8 city lots. Five of these lots are vacant with access to both power and city water. This home would make a great rental with possible future development. 1399 E Paxton Depot Street is just west of the home and across Cedar Street. This lot is  .85 of an acre, and has an old home that may be removed, depending on how ambitious the new owners are. An older garage is also present which is in decent shape.  As with 1431, the county has this divided into 2 multiple lots. If you're looking for a home with a larger lot size or a small investment property, schedule a property visit with Jeff Michalic. Contact him by phone at 812-230-4503 or by Email at

Additional Information


  • shed

Ask Jeff About This Property